Thursday, September 4, 2008

Passengers on the Health Train Express


Quote of the day:

Confusion is always the most honest response. - Marty Indik

******************************************************

Our express train has many cars, pulled by a locomotive. If the train gets too long, another locomotive is added to pull or push the train along with its passengers, and freight.

The train is not as important as the riders, they are the ones on a mission, going to work, going home, going somewhere to be productive, vacation, and enjoy their freedoms in our great country. 

What is critical is that the locomotives are synchronized and pulling together and not in opposite directions.

     I will post some observations about the state of affairs in California, after this diversion. But then again, read this

It does not take a rocket scientist to observe that the political and legislative process is unable to resolve political party differences in transforming health care financing and policy.

Stuck in their universal payor vs open market competition, politicians fail to think out of the box.

Studies abound, with only temporary fixes, based upon budgetary crises, and the fact that most of medical administration is stuck in the early 1960s.

Medicare was ill conceived to begin with, yet now sets a standard for all insurers and payors,  Ironically, when medicare was first legislated it was designed to duplicate standard indemnity health coverage and cover 80% of the usual and standard fee.  (a concept long gone).   As governmental health spending increased, it became  a dominant driving force in the market.  It rapidly fueled inflation in the late 60s through the mid 80s.  The availablilty of 'easy money' for providers and hospitals was a temptation. Not because hospitals and providers were intentionally greedy, nor commiting fraud.  Prior to 1964 there were fewer elderly, and those without coverage fell into the charity safety-net of hospitals, or were given free care....hospitals almost never sent anyone to collections, there was an unwritten word that 'doctors' would figure something out to make sure their patient could receive the necessary attention and care.  It was far from an ideal system, but the diagnostic and treatment options were far less expensive.

So where do we go from here?  I am not against standards set by states, or perhaps the federal government ie  "universal standards v. universal payor.  Let's face it in the United States Universal Payor sound like socialism....not a good word in a republic.  

What is Universal Payor going to cover?

 free parking

Adding to our dilemna is there is no real uniform policy regarding actual health care costs for each patient as related to billing and reimbursement by hospitals.  Different standards apply to different methods of payment....prepaid, capitated, DRGs, and individual contracting (largely influenced by market share)

It is difficult enough to analyze and plan health systems within the context of politics.  Politics should not reign over health care.  As long as there are resources to insure health care availablity politics seems to keep out of the patient's and providers private business.  As soon as there is not enough resources, then the government comes into play.

New Orleans

New Orleans, and the surrounding areas of Louisiana,Missippi, Alabama and Texas are faced with yet another challenge.  However this time they were prepared by being proactive. There was intense cooperation between many disparate organizations for the better good.

What a terrific example and inspiration for success...These folks did not have much of a choice, and what happened was not totally dependent upon financing, under very adverse conditions.

It was a life or death decision to survive.

To me, the comparison between that scenario and health care is obvious.  Can we survive if we do nothing? Can we come together to overcome our disparity?  Will we drown if we do nothing?

CAN WE BE PROACTIVE?

 

Do we have inspirational leaders who can step back, make decisions, or will we continue to have 'committee meetings" and never ending micromanagement, fixes and patches to shore up our dysfunctional health system?

The balkanization of United States health care has created a churning mixture of oil and water, immiscible...the only thing that keeps it going is the constant stirring of the cauldron.  The surge of water over topping the canals reminds me of our system being overwhelmed as well.

Let's pray for the people of the Gulf States.  Volunteer your time, raise funds, give generously to the Red Cross, and your faith based organizations whose mission is to aid the flood victims.

Schedule for the Health Train Express

timex-tx54

The Thumbnail Timex

Next time you want to check your timepiece for the arrival of the health train express, you can literally put your finger on it (or thumb as the case may be.  This mini-timex was developed as a design concept for Timex.  This one literally takes "a licking and keeps on ticking".

Okay, a bit off topic, however the political conventions have me at a disadvantage.

Sunday, August 31, 2008

Congressional Health Train Express

 

Quote of the day:


The greatest pleasure in life is doing what people say you cannot do. - Walter Bagehot

********************************************************

The response to my recent email newsletter was surprising and encouraging.  I had a response that I wish to share with all of you.

Healthcare in the United States is on the crux of great change. During change we have broken the inertia and are able to more easily transform the system during the period of plasticity.

One proposal is in the U.S. Senate Bill  SB 1019 sponsored by Senator Tom Coburn.  Jim Rowsey MD an alumnus (along with me) of GW Medical School has been working with Senator Coburn. Together, they have prepared this video, which I would like to share with you, and ask you to forward it to colleagues.  Note that there are links in this presentation for you to prepare a letter for your senator.  Click the "A Message......

A Message from Senator Tom Coburn M.D. and Jim Rowsey M.D.

 

You may also notice a change to the logo of the  web site. This was the winning entry from a highly competitive list of suggestions.

Saturday, August 30, 2008

I'm sorry the system is too busy to take your call


Quote of the day:


Whenever you have an efficient government you have a dictatorship. - Harry S Truman

 

Beginning Oct. 1, Comcast will put a 250 gigabyte-a-month cap on residential users. The limit will not affect most users, at least not in the short-term, but is certain to create tension as some technologies gain traction.  Whether or not this might extend to commercial usage, such as Health 2.0, or Web 2.0 is not addressed in this announcement from Comcast. Certainly as technological advances proceed it is difficult to predict when 'excessive use' becomes the average utilization. The  use of PAC systems, streaming video, mobile phone solutions, remote at home monitoring, and connectivity among health care sectors is growing exponentially.

In other news,  the FAA suffered a catastrophic breakdown of it's Atlanta operations center last week, causing delays in air traffic routing for several hours.  The FAA's system is outdated and obsolete, despite a decade old effort to upgrade it. The FAA has two centers, one in Atlanta, and another in Salt Lake City. This allows for some redundancy, however, neither center is capable of providing full support without overload. The two videos which follow indicate the seriousness of this problem.

Personnel problems

 

Technical Issues

 

Why is this important to healthcare?  It places in serious doubt whether the federal government is capable  of designing, installing, or maintaining a nationwide system, something Health IT interests, providers, payors, hospitals and safety net providers  should pay close attention.  Governmental process grinds along, inexorably slow, and incapable of keeping up with technological advances that health care depends upon. The governmental role might be to encourage adoption of national standards.

Comments are welcome, and welcome to all our new readers and subscribers. The response has been  awesome!!

Friday, August 29, 2008

The Temple of Obama


Quote of the day:

The world is governed more by appearances than realities, so that it is fully as necessary to seem to know something as to know it. - Daniel Webster

I couldn't ask for a better quote of the day after last night's Graeco-Roman festival.  Where were the gladiators?

 

I have been away from the blog for several days, longer than I realized.  My focus has been on the DNC and RNC conventions.

I did not hear much in the way of real programs, just left vs right, man vs. woman, black vs. white, free market vs socialism, more taxes vs. less taxes, more spending vs. less spending and what it used to be like in the 1950s  which gave me kind of a warm fuzzy

Obama is not just a great orator, but a mass hypnotist. His voice carries with it a kind of "fragrance" that overpowers your ear, and resonates somewhere in the limbic system.  Whatever it is about his voice and resonance we should study it carefully and bottle it, to be re-broadcast at some time in the future when all is about to be lost. I am concerned that somewhere in all that oratory he left us with a post-hypnotic suggestion, which will be unleashed at some unknown time in the future. (perhaps at the polling places in November). So wear your earplugs and eye blinders when you go to the polls.

I had to get that off my chest.  Tomorrow I will be rational again.

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Health Train Express is Overheating


Quote of the day:
A Hospital is no place to be sick. - Samuel Goldwyn

Medical bloggers have become recognized by some as "trouble-makers" by the powers that be.....a sure sign of increasing and recognizable influence on health care and it's reform.

My friend Dimitriy Kruglyak also known as "Hippocrates"

Hippocrates

on the blog, Trusted.MD writes about his views on medical blogging.

Dimitrity, by the way is not a  physician. While most bloggers and others do not realize it Mr Kruglyak who has received little recognition for his "ground breaking" blog was about four years

groundbreaking

ahead of the curve in terms of blogging and aggregated blog commentary.   He also should be credited with developing and producing the first Health 2.0 national symposium.The appearance of the blog may seem funky to all you bloggers, however Mr. Kruglyak was so far ahead of his time that he had to develop his own software to blog.

Trusted.MD  founding contributors have been Rob Lambert,Musings of a Distractible Mind Steve Beller,Quality Advocate)  Sid Schwab (Surgeon's blog), Joseph Kim,  Joseph Kim, MD, MPH. K.Cohn Healthcare Collaboration Blog, yours truly, and others.

Dimitriy makes some very interesting observations, and also how ludricous our medical societies have become and how far out of touch they are with members and non-members.

Dimitriy's unrecognized contribution was  seminal and awesome in regard to medical blogging. (I am certain when he reads this, he will be uncomfortable, shuffle a bit, and blush.). He was prescient in regards to blogs, and perhaps their ultimate contribution to health reform.

The reasons I bring all of this to the forefront is to connect his observations and very accurate predictions about proposed "regulation, and censorship of bloggers opinions". in regard to ethics and conduct.

Sunday, August 24, 2008

Elder Train Express


Quote of the day:
It is our responsibilities, not ourselves, that we should take seriously. - Peter Ustinov

Karen Stevenson Brown is an accomplished student and advocate for the elderly.  I thought I knew a great deal about the concerns and care of the elderly when I stumbled upon her web site and blogs....boy was I surprised.

assisted living

  Karen (she is not the lassie in the cartoon) was stamped out of good old midwestern soil.... the kind of soil where you knew your neighbors well, and in a time where family's cared for their parents and close relatives. The family was more than 'nuclear', it included the electrons, and all participated in sharing and supporting the family unit. Children were expected to contribute,

Econ13B

not only with chores, but for financial needs that in many cases parents could not meet.

Her historical notes outline how we got from there to here, and why our medical financial support system gradually spiralled out of control.

Anyone interested in how our modern day social welfare system(s) evolved and disintegrated needs to thoroughly review her website.

Elderweb

Some of the material is dated, but presents a source for current updates.

History of Long Term Care

One can extrapolate how depersonalized the actual financing of care for parents and elderly relatives has become in the United States.

Karen Stevenson Brown has travelled the country,  holds several advanced degrees and has been involved in long term care for decades.

She has received many awards and media recognition from the likes of  Forbes, Time magazine, and others which you can review by clicking on the above link.

for her unique focus on resources for the elderly, their family, caregivers, long term care administrators, and physicians.

In my humble opinion this is a must read website and reference for any physician who care for elderly or chronically disabled patients.

The Journal of Accountancy credits her with:

"....In 1995 (when the world wide web was still embryonic  she started a Web site to create links to the few resources she could find to help her in her engagements. As more resources began creating their own sites, Brown made more connections, and now ?my site has a life of its own,? she said. Its original plain design has recently gone through a major face lift and organizational upgrade. And the site has become not only a powerful online research tool for clients, government agencies and the general public but also, inadvertently, a marketing tool for its creator. "My practice primarily has been providing services for health care providers. But they don't use the Web much, although consumers of health care for the elderly do; families of the elderly now consult me and my site, for example. So now I work with consumers who ask me, 'Where do I go to get help?'....."

Anyone in health care financial administration needs to read this, and contemplate that maybe the good old days were better.........

Saturday, August 23, 2008

Next stop, Grand Central Station


Quote of the day:


No man is exempt from saying silly things; the mischief is to say them deliberately. - Michel de Montaigne

There are many bloggers: To post or not to post who are for more eloquent and gifted writers than I am.

Lincoln

And some are eloquent speakers

I often read their blogs, or columns and think...that's how I feel, or think.....how come I did not say that out loud

Loud

or write it down?  Perhaps one of the factors is lack of time....It could involve my whole day and night, if I freely associate....I would even have to write down my dreams....

I think of myself as a visionary and futurist.....so perhaps it is a blessing to those around me that I don't broadcast everything that comes to mind.   It would be like all those teeny boppers marching around the mall on their cell phones...

kids on cell phone

(who pays for their airtime?), or those loud rude people on cell phones  in the grocery line telling all those around them about their personal grocery list, or their laundry list.  

The measure of success of a blog is to stimulate those who read them...

 

it needs to relate to them, and also be entertaining. It should contain links to other sites, which are authored by really smart, artistic, or silly authors.  I get pretty bored without 'pictures'. I must be arrested at the third grade level... 

By  now you have realized there is nothing about health care today.

I have stepped off Health Train Express at this stop to transfer to another line.

rural train station

Wait one, my cell is ringing, "hello...no I won't forget to pick up the milk on the way home....luv ya...thanks for calling"

(Ticket Please!)

ticket please

Thursday, August 21, 2008

The Red Eye Health Train Express


Quote of the day:

Thanks to TV and for the convenience of TV, you can only be one of two kinds of human beings, either a liberal or a conservative. - Kurt Vonnegut

 

A lot of people when they get into bed at night turn on the television, and also read a book.

bedside

 

Me, I put my laptop apple air on my

tummy,

 rub_mah_tummy and surf the net, read and research my interests in health policy reform.  There is no shortage of pundits in this realm.  However tonite, as I was watching the olympics with one eye and the proceedings on my laptop my mind forgot all about the birdsnest2 .  It was interesting that in the relays the U.S. team dropped the baton in both the women's and the men's relays.  Undoubtedly the United States had the finest track team but 'dropped the ball' and was disqualified.  Sound familiar?  One could say the same thing about our system....in pieces it is the best health  care in the world, however overall we too fail to pass the baton, and are disqualified. 

As the evening went on I came to "The Shattuck Lecture" sponsored by the NEJM and the Massachussetts Medical Society.

The lecture is also available in a video format . It is well worth the time to watch.  The most interesting thing is that there was nothing the panel stated that physicians and patients don't already know.  Some of the proposed solutions bordered on the ridiculous and were contradictory.  I leave it to you to see the video or read the transcripts....they talk the talk, now let's see if they walk the talk.  They agree with my contention that a president should not be selected based upon his health care proposal for reform.  This will not be nor should be a presidential decision....it's up to the people and the congress.  Stay tuned,

Health Train Lawyers


Quote of the day:

The great enemy of clear language is insincerity. When there is a gap between one's real and one's declared aims, one turns as it were instinctively to long words and exhausted idioms, like a cuttlefish spurting out ink. - George Orwell

medicaid red ink

How much will this cost the people of California?  (for lawyers)

Attorneys for the people, and the federal government:

Judge blocks state's cut in Medi-Cal fees
San Francisco Chronicle - 08-20-2008 - A federal judge has blocked California's 10 percent cut in Medi-Cal fees for doctors, dentists and pharmacies, saying the money-saving measures appear to violate federal law and would worsen medical care for millions of poor people. In her ruling Monday, U.S. District Judge Christina Snyder of Los Angeles said she was aware of California's gaping deficit, now $17.2 billion (including $2 billion in reserves) with the budget 50 days overdue and legislators still deadlocked. But she said the state has accepted federal funds for Medi-Cal and is bound to use them to provide quality health care to low-income residents... Dr. Richard Frankenstein, president of the California Medical Association, said this was the third ruling in five years to conclude that "the state of California has put at risk the access to health care for millions of Californians by underfunding the Medi-Cal program." He was referring to a previous state attempt to reduce fees to health providers, overturned by the courts

medicaid budget bal

vs.

Attorneys for the State of California

State officials plan to appeal Medi-Cal ruling

Elizabeth Fernandez, Chronicle Staff Writer

Thursday, Aug 21, 2008

(08-20) 18:04 PDT SAN FRANCISCO -- State officials are planning to appeal a federal judge's decision this week that blocked 10 percent cuts in Medi-Cal fees to doctors, pharmacists and other medical professionals.

  • The state also plans to ask next week for a reconsideration and a stay of the decision by U.S. District Judge Christina Snyder of Los Angeles, contending her ruling would cost California $575 million a year. The state is confronting a $17.2 billion shortfall for the fiscal year that began on July 1. The state has been without a budget since that date.

"We believe this ruling can be overturned," H.D. Palmer, a spokesman for the California Department of Finance, said today. "When we first proposed (the cut) in January, we knew it was difficult but necessary. We need to achieve these savings."

Doctors and other health-care professionals, however, hailed the ruling, saying it stops Medi-Cal from being decimated. "It really is great news for those who provide health-care, but also for Medi-Cal patients," said Dr. Ronald Labuguen, who sits on the board of the California Academy of Family Physicians. He practices medicine at San Francisco General Hospital.It's been very difficult for patients in a lot of communities to get the kind of care they need," he said. "It is hard to express how big a victory this is. A lot of patients are going to the emergency room or to urgent care services when they could be better served if they had a regular health-care provider."

elephant-in-the-room

The Elephant in the Room

emergency waiting room

Emergency Waiting Room

The 10 percent reductions took effect last month to a large network of doctors, dentists, pharmacists, adult day health centers, and others in the health-care system. Some 6.6 million low-income people receive Medi-Cal.In her ruling, Snyder said Medi-Cal patients would be "irreparably harmed" by the cuts.Dr. Bo Greaves, a Santa Rosa physician who runs a private, primary-care practice, called the decision "a step away from the wrong direction.""The current reimbursement was so substandard - for them to reduce it by another 10 percent was appalling. It would have created a crisis for the entire state," Greaves said.

Monday, August 18, 2008

Counting Sheep


Quote of the day:

Procrastination isn't the problem, it's the solution. So procrastinate now, don't put it off. - Ellen DeGeneres

 

It's always a mistake for me to look at blogs just before bedtime. I usually come across articles and/or issues that defy normal logic and/or thought.

Just when you thought EMRs were the answer to everything I come across this:

Proposal To Move to ICD-10 Coding System Stalled

image

An effort to adopt new health care coding standards that some experts say might be more compatible with electronic medical records has stalled, according to an industry group advocating the changes, Healthcare IT News reports.
Some organizations - such as the American Health Information Management Association and the American Hospital Association - say switching from the current ICD-9 clinical coding system to the ICD-10 clinical coding system would provide more accurate data that would be better suited to EMRs. However, AHIMA Vice President Dan Rode said the government does not appear to be taking action to update the coding system. "Until the government gives us a green light, we're not going to have vendors implement it," he added.
The cost of switching to the ICD-10 system is a major concern, Healthcare IT News reports. BlueCross and BlueShield Association officials said they are worried that updating the codes would be too costly, especially as providers work to comply with HIPAA regulations and attempt to adopt EMRs (Broder, Healthcare IT News, 3/7).
A report released in fall 2003 by BCBS said switching to ICD-10 could cost the health care industry up to $14 billion over two to three years. A RAND study commissioned by National Committee on Vital and Health Statistics found that hospital implementation of ICD-10 could cost from $425 million to $1.5 billion, plus $5 million to $40 million annually in lost productivity. The same report, however, found the benefits of adoption could range from $700 million to $7.7 billion (iHealthBeat, 11/6/2003).
AHIMA says that EMRs would not yield much benefit unless the code is updated, and the AHA wants to switch to ICD-10 because it says ICD-9 is outdated and does not allow for accurate coding, Healthcare IT News reports (Healthcare IT News, 3/7).

Now mind you, that was  from March 2005.  Jump forward to 2008.

image

On Friday, HHS issued a proposed rule that would require health care providers to adopt ICD-10 code sets for electronic health transactions by October 2011, Government Health IT reports (Ferris, Government Health IT News, 8/16).
Health care providers currently use ICD-9 code sets, which were developed about 30 years ago and no longer can be expanded effectively to include codes for new diseases and procedures. ICD-9 can accommodate about 17,000 codes, while ICD-10 had space for more than 155,000 codes (Health Data Management, 8/15).
In a statement, HHS Secretary Mike Leavitt said that adopting ICD-10 code sets is a necessary step toward developing a Nationwide Health Information Infrastructure. He added, "The greatly expanded ICD-10 code sets will enable HHS to fully support quality reporting, pay for performance, biosurveillance and other critical activities."
Acting CMS Administrator Kerry Weems acknowledged that the conversion would entail some additional costs, but he added that delaying the conversion only would increase such costs. Weems pledged to "work collaboratively across the health care system to ensure a smooth transition" (Government Health IT, 8

Providers-Mortgage Your Home for your Patients

 

Budget impasse halts Medi-Cal payments

This article from the Ventura County Star is a shocking account of how irresponsible our California State Government is. Rather than prioritizing health care for disabled patients they will plan huge expenses for prison hospitals, pork barrel projects, and other non essential 'luxuries'...  Shame on Them....Shame on Us for allowing this.

Truth Out Describes the issues in New York and California

This group of patients is the most vulnerable, and requires the advocacy of every physician whether they accept medi-caid patients, or not.