The Affordable Care Act, Accountable Care Organization and the Election

Better Together Health 2016 Event - Better Together     Are we really

The Affordable Care Act has stimulated many changes in health care. What is  considered good or bad depends upon the viewpoint of the provider and/or patient.

We have not yet seen the details of the Republican plan so Health Train Express will not offer our evaluation. Decisions based upon political rhetoric are at the least foolish, and at the worst dangerous.

It is doubtful if the ACA will be repealed entirely. Significant amendments ill be made. Other than some displeasure in the provider and health insurance industry patients who are able to access care are at less risk of not getting urgent care.  Even that presents problems in terms of provider accesss and the high deductible and premium expence for most receiving a partial subsidy. For those who are indigent, they have not expenses.

The progress of the organization being promoted by Medicare and some private insurers is the Accountable Care Organization (ACO).  The progress of developing this organization is fraught with many barriers. The ACO is an HMO on steroids.

Perhaps the closest organization to an ACO is the Kaiser Permanente model. The Counsel of Associated Physicians Group recently held a symposium, Better Together Health 2016 Event - Better Together.

The speakers represent a broad spectrum of the view on Accountable Care Organizations.

ROBERT PEARL, MD   CHAIR, COUNCIL OF ACCOUNTABLE PHYSICIAN PRACTICES
Robert Pearl, MD, is Executive Director and CEO of The Permanente Medical Group and President and CEO of the Mid-Atlantic Permanente Medical Group. Dr. Pearl serves on the faculties of the Stanford University School of Medicine and Graduate School of Business. Dr. Pearl is a frequent lecturer on the opportunities to use 21st century tools and technology to improve both the quality and cost of health care, while simultaneously making care more convenient and personalized.

SENATOR JOHNNY ISAKSON    (R-GA), CO-CHAIR, SENATE FINANCE COMMITTEE CHRONIC CARE WORKING GROUP

Senator John Hardy Isakson (R-GA) is serving his second term in the U.S. Senate, and was recently tapped to lead the Senate Finance Committee’s Chronic Care Solutions working group with Senator Mark Warner (D-VA). The work of the bipartisan committee is to begin exploring solutions that will improve outcomes for Medicare patients requiring chronic care. Isakson is the first Georgian since the 1800s to have served in the state House, state Senate, U.S. House of Representatives and U.S. Senate. He also serves on the Senate HELP Committee, Senate Finance Committee, the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, the Senate Ethics Committee, and the Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee.

TIM GRONNIGEr    DEPUTY CHIEF OF STAFF, DIRECTOR OF DELIVERY SYSTEM REFORM AT CMS
Tim Gronniger is the deputy chief of staff and director of delivery system reform at CMS. He was formerly a senior adviser for healthcare policy at the White House Domestic Policy Council (DPC), where he was responsible for coordinating administration activities in healthcare delivery system reform. Before joining DPC he was a senior professional staff member for Ranking Member Henry Waxman at the House Committee on Energy and Commerce, responsible for drafting and collaborating to develop elements of the Affordable Care Act. Before joining the Committee staff, Tim spent over four years at the Congressional Budget Office.

CECI CONNOLLY    PRESIDENT AND CEO, ALLIANCE OF COMMUNITY HEALTH PLANS

Ceci Connolly became president and CEO of the Alliance of Community Health Plans in January 2016. In her role, she works with some of the most innovative executives in the health sector to provide high-quality, evidence-based, affordable care. Connolly has spent more than a decade in health care, first as a national correspondent for The Washington Post and then in thought leadership roles at two international consulting firms. She is a leading thinker in the disruptive forces shaping the health industry and has been a trusted adviser to C-suite executives who share her commitment to equitable, patient-centered care.

KAREN CABELL, DO    CHIEF OF QUALITY AND PATIENT SAFETY, BILLINGS CLINIC

Dr. Karen Cabell is the chief of quality and patient safety and a practicing internal medicine physician at Billings Clinic, an integrated medical foundation healthcare organization, located in Billings, Montana. Dr. Cabell has implemented diabetes, heart failure and HTN disease management registries along with point-of-care tools for patients and clinicians to better manage chronic disease. She was involved with Billings’ rollout and adoption of an electronic health record implementation since 2004 including all clinic sites and regional partners to include 15 other hospitals with clinics across a 500-mile radius. Dr. Cabell has been instrumental in gaining alignment between the EHR, quality and patient safety as well as strategic planning to support Billings Clinic’s organizational goals of clinical excellence, operational efficiency, market growth and development, and financial strength.

REGINA HOLLIDAY    PATIENT RIGHTS ACTIVIST, ARTIST, AUTHOR

Artist Regina Holliday is a patient advocate known for her series of murals depicting the need for clarity and transparency in medical records, and for founding the Walking Gallery movement. The Walking Gallery consists of more than 350 volunteer members who make statements about the lapses in health care at public meetings by wearing business suits or blazers painted with patient stories. Holliday’s experiences during her husband’s illness and subsequent death inspired her to use painting as a catalyst for change. Backed by her own patient and caregiving experiences, she travels the globe heralding her message of patient empowerment and inclusion in healthcare decision making. Holliday’s mission is to demand a thoughtful dialog with officials and practitioners on the role patients play in their own healthcare.

MARC KLAU, MD

ASSISTANT REGIONAL MEDICAL DIRECTOR, SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA PERMANENTE MEDICAL GROUP

Dr. Marc Klau has been with the Southern California Permanente Medical Group for 31 years. He is currently the regional chief of Head and Neck Surgery, providing leadership for 100 surgeons.  He is also the Assistant Regional Medical Director for Education, Learning and Leadership. He now oversees the new KP School of Medicine and all of the Southern California Kaiser Permanente residencies, as well as continuing medical education and leadership.

JANET MARCHIBRODA

Artist Regina Holliday is a patient advocate known for her series of murals depicting the need for clarity and transparency in medical records, and for founding the Walking Gallery movement. The Walking Gallery consists of more than 350 volunteer members who make statements about the lapses in health care at public meetings by wearing business suits or blazers painted with patient stories. Holliday’s experiences during her husband’s illness and subsequent death inspired her to use painting as a catalyst for change. Backed by her own patient and caregiving experiences, she travels the globe heralding her message of patient empowerment and inclusion in healthcare decision making. Holliday’s mission is to demand a thoughtful dialog with officials and practitioners on the role patients play in their own healthcare.

DIRECTOR, HEALTH INNOVATION INITIATIVE, BIPARTISAN POLICY CENTER

Janet Marchibroda is the director of the Bipartisan Policy Center’s Health Innovation Initiative in Washington, DC. She has been recognized as one of the Top 25 Women in Healthcare by Modern Healthcare and is a nationally recognized expert on the use of health IT to improve healthcare quality.

LEANA WEN, MD  HEALTH COMMISSIONER, BALTIMORE CITY

Since taking the reins of America’s oldest health department in Baltimore, Dr. Leana Wen has been reimagining the role of public health including in violence prevention, addiction treatment, and urban revitalization. Under Dr. Wen’s leadership, the Baltimore City Health Department has launched an ambitious overdose prevention program that is training every resident to save lives, as well as a citywide youth health and wellness plan. She is the author of the book, When Doctors Don’t Listen: How to Avoid Misdiagnoses and Unnecessary Tests, and is regularly featured on National Public Radio, CNN, New York Times, and Washington Post. Her talk on TED.com on transparency in medicine has been viewed nearly 1.5 million times.

Better Together Health 2016 Event - Better Together

The Future Just Passed

Things are changing quickly, at first it was little things like you are now a primary care provider instead of a GP or Family Physician. Today I read that we are now First Level Providers , or Second Level Providers instead of a specialist. What's in a name....?  Everything. Nomenclature often defines the culture, and new vocabulary and abbreviations change the way we think, write and do.

I am now lumped in with "Vision Care Providers"....which seems to lump me in with Opticians, and Optometrists.   One thing I was always challenged with is the relative lack of sophistication and/or knowledge as to the difference between and O.D. (Optometrist) and M.D. (Ophthalmologist).  In recent years Optometrists become certified in therapeutics for treatment of some eye conditions.  The threshold for medical treatment has been lowered substantially.

Health Reform iinvolves both quantity and quality of health care. During the most recent decades there are many who argue that quantity does not equate with quality of care.  Measuring quality is challenging at to where to look.  Recent ideas include better outcomes (ostensibly measured by the number of reductions in readmission after hospitalization within the first 30 days of discharge.  That metric however encompasses a small measure of health delivery.

The  outpatient, or ambulatory service setting presents the majority of health expense and visits, save for long term care of the aged population.

The affordable care act will markedly increase outpatient services for states who have opted-in for medicaid expansion.  This will be covered in an upcoming edition.

FEDERAL HEALTH BENEFIT EXCHANGES: COVERED CALIFORNIA, BREAKING NEWS

Exchange enrollments at 3.3 million, big jump in January

By Paul Demko 

Posted: February 12, 2014 - 5:15 pm ET

Tags: Costs, HealthCare.gov, Insurance

(Story updated at 6:15 p.m. ET)

Nearly 3.3 million individuals signed up for private insurance plans through the state and federal exchanges during the first four months of the open enrollment period, HHS reported Wednesday. The total represents significant growth in January, but is still less than halfway toward the goal of 7 million enrollments by March 31.

State exchanges enrolled 1.4 million individuals through the end of January, while 1.9 million individuals signed up through the federal exchange, according to figures released by the CMS on Wednesday. The federal exchange, in particular, showed momentum in January: Nearly 40% of total enrollments through the federal HealthCare.gov website occurred last month. 

It's very, very encouraging news,” HHS Secreatary Kathleen Sebelius said on a call with reporters Wednesday.  

However the total numbers only show a small part of the enrollment issues.  Demographics vary widely from state to state in terms of age, health, and gender.

“We're seeing a growing population of Americans who are young, healthy and well covered, and these younger Americans are signing up in greater proportions,” Sebelius said.

A significant number of new enrollees are from those who had pre-existing policies cancelled at the end of 2013.

Catastrophic Options

Hardship Exemptions  (Qualifications)

However, in some states exchange customers continue to skew significantly older. In Ohio and Wisconsin, for example, only 21% of enrollees were between the ages of 18 and 34.

A gender discrepancy is also emerging, with women representing 55% of those seeking coverage. In some states, the gender imbalance is even more pronounced. Women account for 60% of signups in Oregon and 62% of exchange customers in Mississippi.

HHS also issued data for the first time on the type of plans being purchased on the exchanges. More than 60% of state and federal exchange customers opted for silver plans, which are designed to cover 70% of medical costs

Last week, the Congressional Budget Office reduced its estimate for how many people will sign up for coverage in 2014 from 7 million to 6 million, due in part to the rocky rollout of the federal exchange and continued problems with some state marketplaces. 

There is still no data available on how many individuals have actually made their first premium payment. Even after enrollment and premium payment it remains to be seen how many will find a suitable provider. Magnifying this issue in California is massive errors in the provider directory listing providers who will not accept Covered California.

A massive  deception has been built into Covered California. Policies called Blue Shield PPO (Silver  Plan) are not ordinary Blue Shield PPO plans.  Not only that but there is a difference between group PPO plans and Individual Family Plans (IFP).

I contacted a wel established medical group (Inland Empire)  (120 providers)  to inquire about their providers enrolled in Covered California. I was told tthey accept the group Blue Shield PPO, but NOT the IFP. 

This will come as a great shock to those enrolled in many Covered California plans.

Precautionary note:  Check with your chosen provider to ascertain if they accept your specific plan under Covered California. Covered Callifornia is a general term and means very little. Be certain to find if the specific plan that was signed up for is truly available.

Many patients will present to the doctor's office and find they do not have a provider.

Important News:  Covered California is updating it's Provider  Directory.  Check with your chosen provider to corroborate their participation.  Urgent Care Centers are also specific to a planBe certain your chosen provider is aa member of the medical staff of your chosen hospital.

The Health Benefit Exchanges say that enrollment can be changed until March 31.2014.  

Note: This article will be updated weekly.

Affordable Care Act.......The Missing Link....It is not Australopithecus

Houston, we  have a problem  "Failure to Launch"

Despite a goal of access to health care for all, however the hinge on the door for acccess is squeaking. News such as this are appearing in medical news.

Family Planning Clinics In Calif. Squeezed By Health Law KQED - February 10, 2014 Millions Trapped in Health-Law Coverage Gap Wall Street Journal - February 9, 2014 They quit their jobs, thanks to health-care law Washington Post - February 9, 2014 Enrolling in Covered California is not for the weak of heart, or spirit.  For those who were previously uninsured for a variety of reasons the affordable care act raise spirits with the elimination of the fear of not being able to pay for health care. The current system was not sustainable financially, however health care is available taking away the financial morass of insurance companies, bureaucracy and government.  Neither government, nor insurance companies provide health care. Physiciains, nurses, hospitals and many other providers care for patients. A consequence of the change will be the marked reduction in 'free care'. The old model of those fortunate enough to pay for their own care, and providers and hospitals having deep pockets to finance care for the less priveleged of our society. In order to assure health care and security for all the down side is forfeiting freedom. The tyranny of absolute security is freedom. Some of  us understand the concept and the reason for opposition to the affordable care act.  Others see it as an opportunity   for free health care.   Those whol will receive this generosity are often not only uninsured, but also un-empowered, and have little impact, are passive and do not have resources, nor influence to make changes. The U.S. Constitution (    )  guarrantees the pursuit of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.  That statement places us in a conundrum.  Does that mean care to avoid illness, or treatment to keep one alive? This is not some ephemeral abstract thought embodied in our founding document. Other constitutional guarrantees in the past have been manipulated to make change The Affordable Care Act in Californa is known as  'Covered California'.  Patients who sign up are screened for eligibilty based on income and household size. Those who's income is greater than........are required to purchase a subsidized health insurance policy or face a fine.  Some of these policies look nice, offered by stable companies, such as Blue Shield, Healthnet, Anthem and their providers are listed under providers for Covered California.  However with a more in depth search you will find they did not receive contracts and are not providers.  (small details).....this will reduce access to providers (and some hospitals). None of this has been adequatly explained  Some who look forward to using Covered California should call their chosen provider and ask if they are a provider for Covered California.   Many of them are not, and some may not even know if they are signed up for it.

Feeling the Pain ? ACO ACA HIX HIE HHS CMS ICD10

We physicians have some difficulty objectively measuring pain.  Even subjectively it becomes a challenge when your patient asks for pain medications.

The standard of medical practice now is to ask, "What is your pain level from 1-10 if 10 would be the worst pain  you have ever felt, and 0 is no pain whatsoeverl.  Even this scale is very subjective and is based upon what that patient considers his worst pain.  That depends on many factors. Patients who have never had any pain would not know what the worst pain would be.  Pain thresholds differ greatly from one patient to ano ther.  Comparing one patient to another with  this metric is meaningless.  Perhaps we should set a standard as labor pains. This standard however would only apply to women.

All of the above acronyms are a feature of health reform, which is not painless. The medical lexicon includes countless three letter or four letter acronyms, which are too lengthy to describe here.

ACO, ICD-10, MU, PCMH, and PQRS are more than just an acronym soup. 

Karen DeSalvo now the head of ONC and a former primary care physician from Louisana is the lady for the job of reducing our pain. (perhaps hypnosis, denial, or retirment would be better than the narcotic of acceptance and/or major revision of how government interacts with healthcare.

Diana Manos of Health IT News describes DeSalvo's background: 

To advance America’s triple aim of improving the experience of care, improving the health of populations, and reducing per capita costs of healthcare, DeSalvo outlined five key goals, which ONC will be focused on over this, the second decade of its work.

They are:

1. Increase end user adoption of health IT
2. Establish standards so the various technologies can speak to each other
3. Provide the right incentives for the market to drive this advancement
4. Make sure personal health information remains private and secure
5. Provide governance and structure for health IT

DeSalvo believes interoperability remains the most important issue as a framework for Health Reform.

Despite more than half a decade of progress, Interoperability appears to have stalled.

Michael Schatzlein MD 

of Asencio Health describes the current status of interoperabillity and it's future in the world of the internet.  It's greatest hope is the present generation of internet enabled patients who will demand interoperability, perhaps at the ballot box if bureaucrats cannot accomplish the goal..  The federal government has already invested billions of dollars of your tax money toward this goal.

Ideologues and Unrealistic Expectations

Comments from Gary Levin MD are underlined and italicized:

Today I am amazed at an enthusiastic article about the Affordable Care Act by Eugene Robinson from Tallahassee.com.

His unbridled enthusiasm in the face of many difficulties that have nothing to do with health care exemplifies those who designed this law and passed it without reading it.

Here are some of his unsubtantiated claims and perhaps 'wishful thinking'

Eugene Robinson:  Washington Post

"Now that the fight over Obamacare is history, perhaps everyone can finally focus on making the program work the way it was designed. Or, preferably, better.

The fight is history, you realize. Done. Finito. Yesterday’s news.

Any existential threat to the Affordable Care Act ended with the popping of champagne corks as the new year arrived. That was when an estimated 6 million uninsured Americans received coverage through expanded Medicaid eligibility or the federal and state health insurance exchanges. Obamacare is now a fait accompli; nobody is going to take this coverage away."

1. The fight is not history, we are barely through round one and all the points go to the opponents of the ACA.

2. Six million Americans have not received coverage from the ACA. Registering is only the first step. It took me over ten hours of fumbling on the web site, and on hold via telephone. How many will be able to pay premiums by deadlines, or negotiate the difficult process of acquiring a provider. 

"There may be more huffing, puffing and symbolic attempts at repeal by Republicans in Congress. There may be continued resistance and sabotage by Republican governors and GOP-controlled state legislatures. But the whole context has changed."

The upside of the ACA is that all previously uninsurable patients now are enrolled no matter what pre-existing condition they have A+++++.

Can the ACA be improved?  Most definitely. The argument should not be Republican against Democrat.  Political party does not immunize one against illness.

I wholly agree with Mr. Robinson's analysis regarding the eventual goal of a uniform health system.  To call it universal care is a misnomer.

"The real problem with the ACA, and let’s be honest, is that it doesn’t go far enough. The decision to work within the existing framework of private, for-profit insurance companies meant building a tremendously complicated new system that still doesn’t quite get the job done: Even if all the states were fully participating, only about 30 million of the 48 million uninsured would be covered.

Yes Obamacare does not go far enough, however that is not the principle flaw. There is no one principle flaw, if there are any that is the poor analysis  and proposed implementation of a major expenditure that will effect most businesses,  all patients, and our national budget, and come up short.  If we are intent, committed and dedicated to these goals then let's get it right (or mostly right the first time)

Obamacare does establish the principle that health care is a right, not a privilege — and that this is true not just for children, the elderly and the poor but for all Americans.

Throughout the nation’s history, it has taken long, hard work to win universal recognition of what we consider our basic rights

This is a political and philosophical statement, not about health care. We need to keep these issues separate.  I agree with him about the tenet that all people should have health care financing.

Our first step should be to put on hold further mandates while the act is re-evaluated. Repeal is not an option, however amendment is a reality and not an 'existential' argument.

Mr Robinson's  article is not objective, nor unbiased. He totally neglects the weaknesses of the law which will require amendments.  Placing the issue in terms of a 'battle' between political parties does disservice to dedicated professionals who have  been in the system,  and who were neglected during the planning process.

To ignored the flaws would be a fatal mistake, health care costs will soar and there will still be large gaps in the insured population

Contact Eugene Robinson ateugenerobinson@washpost.com.

Contact Gary Levin MD at gmlevinmd@digitalhealthspace.com

Affordable Care Act "It ain't over until it's Over"

If you are reading this blog and waiting for me to tell you what is going to happen in health reform, you have come to the right place.  I know as much about this as Kathleen Sebelius or Barak Obama.

I am certain that makes you all feel better.

I know that is reassuring to my readers, because Obama and Sebelius had access to and heard many learned opinions on developing the affordable care act. However they were not listening and the elephant in the room was political intrigue, and 'what's in it for me ?"

Today my spouse received the magic letter from Covered  California stating that she has qualified, and now all she has to do is go to the website  log-in and pick her (Silver plan) That is no small task.

Among many other things, the subsidies make no logical sense to me (or others)  I need all of my funds to support myself and my disabled wife who has been unable to work for over ten years.  $250 USD would help pay for the pain medication she takes as a result of a bad wrist injury in 2002. After that she was uninsurable, so I am grateful that the ACA now affords her the ability to become insured until she reaches age 65 and  will be eligible for Medicare.

 It seems that my user id and/or password is incorrect, and I do not remember any of the questions, or answers for the security questions. Small wonder....their selection of Q&As is quite a mystery to me. I am so old I don't remember who my best friend in high school was, no the color of my first car, nor my favorite food (I like them all). Whatever happened to my mother's maiden name?

I called the telephone numbers listed on Covered California for lost user ids/passwords, and was either greeted with a busy signal or a 'we are busy right now, go to our web site, coveredca.com. Now would anyone call them if they had not already tried to use the web site.  The live on line chat room brings up a blank white screen.

The ACA has created stress for all of us, not knowing the eventual outcome...success or failure or some point in between  For those whose former policies  have been cancelled I say let's let them get to the front of the line.

It makes a lot of sense......they are already paying customers and the system needs their premium dollars now.

Everyone else should wait several weeks. Another month won't make much difference to those who have not been insured for the past decade or so.

Although I have never liked insurance companies, I do feel empathy for the mess the affordable care act has produced on top of the measly 15% margin they must operate upon now, and all those pre-existing condition patients waiting in the wings.

As Yogi Berra (byname of Lawrence Peter Berra) once told me, "It ain't over, until it's all over"  (Yes, he did tell me that personally when I was a sprite living in Connecticut.)  My Dad took me to at least a hundred Yankee games in the Bronx. I also have a signed Mickey Mantle original photo of the "Bronx Bomber"

So what does that have to do with the ACA? Let's listen and take seriously what Yogi had to say. I trust him, after all he was a Yankee on a team that broke all records winning  7 world series' back to back.

Would you rather trust President Obama, our Congress, or Secretary Sebelius?  After all Yogi batted left handed and threw right handed. (source Wikipedia)/