HEALTH TRAIN EXPRESS Mission: To promulgate health education across the internet: Follow or subscribe to Health Train Express as well as Digital Health Space for all the updates for health policy, reform, public health issues. Health Train Express is published several times a week.Subscribe and receive an email alert each time it is published. Health Train Express has been published since 2006.
What do credit card blogs have to do with health insurance? Read on at Credit card forum (the blog)
Perhaps one of the new regulations in health reform will be a HICO score that parallels your FICO score. Or perhaps we need a 'truth in health insurance " law that parallels the 'truth in lending " law.
Check your HICO score monthly , clean up your health !
Sick people, need not apply!
Docs 4
PATIENT CARE
Ok everyone, we are on the eve of our second big trip to Washington.
It will never be perfect, but as good as it was for everyone last time, I expect that this one will be even better, because we learned a lot from last time and we'll be a bit more organized, I hope.
Enclosed are suggested talking points. Remember, they are SUGGESTED talking points. You can add your own to the list if you think that there is something missing. Please don't ask us to redo this with your point that we left out. 20 doctors can come up with 21 different talking point lists. This list encompasses 95% of the things that we all seem to agree about.
We have some appointments set up. The Congressmen and Senators know about us and word has gotten around about the last trip and this one. The appointments are a bit more scarce this time as a result. Nonetheless, we will go to their offices and try to get in to see them or their chief of staff or their healthcare team.
I have a list of people coming who emailed me. I do not want to put people's names on a mass mailing to confirm that you are coming. So, I'm going to ask anyone coming to just shoot a 1 line email to me today to confirm that we have you on our list. The reason for this, is because we've divided the docs that we have into 4 lobbying groups and we want to make sure that we have you. If you would prefer to be on your own (not advised), then don't bother replying.
All docs will meet in the plaza in front of the Capitol steps at 9:00AM and we will break into groups. There is one exception, the organizers of the Million med March have a 9:00 meeting and I will send a separate email to them about meeting earlier.
We will meet with Congressmen and Senators until about 11:15 and then head over to John MArshall PArk for the Million Med Rally and March.
We will then meet with Congressmen again after the march.
The weather forecast looks good for Thursday- high of 70, and clear.
REMEMBER THAT EVERYONE SHOULD COME WEARING SCRUBS AND WHITE COATS. THIS IS FOR REAL!!. It makes for an impressive show, and that is why we are all taking the time off from our lives to come to Washington. I'm looking forward to seeing all of you there.
Hal
Hal Scherz MD
President, Docs 4 Patient Care
Letter to Congressmen and Senators:
TALKING POINTS FOR CONGRESSIONAL LOBBYING
1. There is no need to rush a bill through just to satisfy a political promise. Healthcare reform needs to be thought out and done carefully. There is only one chance to do this correctly.
2. The problem with healthcare isn’t the care. It is the best care in the world. The quality of US healthcare and the outcomes are being unfairly attacked so that the system can be changed.
3. There are solutions that have been offered to address problems in a targeted fashion that Congress and the White House are not listening to.
4. Access to health insurance is a problem for 15-20 million US citizens. This can be addressed immediately with insurance vouchers and tax credits utilizing the current private insurers.
5. Cost of healthcare insurance is high and needs to come down. This can be done by promoting competition. First by repealing the antitrust exemption that insurance companies operate under (McCarron- Fergusson Act) and by relaxing restrictions on internet sales of healthcare insurance across state lines.
6. Eliminate pre-existing conditions by expanding risk pools and establishing high risk pools.
7. Allow people to purchase their own insurance and receive the same tax breaks as employers. This will uncouple insurance from the workplace and make it portable.
8. Push for Health Savings Accounts to make people better consumers of healthcare resources, which would drive costs down. Other ways to drive costs down would be to have doctors and hospitals post fees so that patients could shop. Eliminate antitrust regulations, Stark regulations, and many other government regulations on doctors which actually drive healthcare costs up.
9. Medical Liability Reform- specialty boards to decide on the merits of cases before they go to trial. Caps on awards, loser pays for frivolous lawsuits.
10. No government run or sponsored health insurance program (public option, coops, insurance exchange, triggers, mandates)
11. No government oversight board determining medical decisions
12. The AMA does not represent the majority of practicing US doctors- only 17% belong to the AMA and most of these are retired, practice academic medicine, are in administration, or are residents and students
13. Our #1 priority is the health and well being of our patients- your constituents (when talking to elected officials)
Put this on your schedule: October 1, 2009 in Washington, D.C.
An Interview with Hal Scherz, MD a Pediatric Urologist. Hal Scherz practices in Atlanta, Georgia..
Hal has taken the bold step of forming a grass roots organization to link individual physicians and groups with patient advocacy groups to visit congressional representatives (U.S. Sentate, and House of Representatives) during the Health Reform debate and afterward.
The organization is ‘DOCS4PATIENTCARE.ORG ‘. The organization also goes by the same name.
Health Train: Hal, tell me about docs4patientcare .
Dr. Scherz: I decided to form a group that would go to Washington DC for the "White Coats to Congress Rally " during the initial march in early September 2009. It was an amazing experience to see so many physicians motivated and willing to take a day from their busy schedule to attend the event.
Health Train: What did you experience at the ‘march’?
Dr Scherz: Several things,
1. We individual physicians have gained an audible voice in the debate and decision making process.
2. Physicians are now willing to participate in grassroots activities outside the cloak of organized medicine.
3. Many physicians do not feel that the AMA or other specialty organizations represent them adequately.
4. The power of individuals is greater than the power collectively of our organizations.
5. Patient advocacy groups and individuals have a greater effect when united in this common goal of insuring that the doctor patient relationship is maintained and strengthened.
6. The people we met in D.C were not political activists, nor radicals. They are ordinary Americans with a passionate message about health reform and the dangers of governmental control and/or intervention in the health process.
Health Train: Where do you go from here?
Dr Scherz:
Our most immediate goal is to gather another group to travel to Washington DC for the ‘Million Med March”. On October 10, 2009.
Health Train: What groups are you affiliated with?
None. We are independent and have no political allegiances or agenda other than making the individual physician’s voices heard.
Health Train: Where are your Chapters?
Dr Scherz: Atlanta, Chicago, Dallas, Indiana, Phoenix, Baltimore, New York
Health Train: How do I join?, Is this a PAC?
Dr Scherz: No, it is not a PAC. You can go to our website: www.docs4patientcare.org to register. We are not a PAC. We merely encourage individuals and empower their activities.
Health Train: When is the next “Event”?
The next ‘Event” The Million Med March" will take place on October 10,2009 in Washington, DC. Details will be posted on the website, www.docs4patientcare.org
Health Train: Can I form my own chapter in my area?
Dr Scherz: Yes ,by all means, we are encouraging joining local chapters or forming your own chapter
Healht Train: Do you want to add anything else?
Dr. Scherz: We are an organization searching for passionate and articulate physicians to go to Washington D.C. and possibly have the opportunity to speak on a national forum regarding pending health reform legislation.
Health Train: Thank you Dr Scherz....we'll see you in Washington on the 1st of October.
For more information go to www.docs4patientcare.org
Most of us realize that our government in D.C. has been out of control for over a decade (perhaps much longer).
According to this interview with Pete Stark, Congressman from California it makes sense that the more debt the government has, the wealthier the country is.
I am not certain of the rationale of this statement but perhaps it alludes to the ability of our government to borrow money reflects upon our income, ability and willingness to make payments on that debt. In October 2008 we came to an abrupt ending to that rhetoric. The past 12 months are a witness to the failure of that economic model . We shall call that "Pete Stark Economics". Perhaps in 30 years or so Mr. Stark will be the Nobel Prize winner in Economics. However I am not holding my breath,
Health IT continues to be in the limelight of health reform. And there is a great deal of scrambling to obtain a share of the stimulus IT funding passed by congress this year.
Two cardiologists from Johns Hopkins University , David Meyerson and Sammy Zakira elaborate in the Washington Post a typical frustrating encounter for the majority of physicians who are confronted by a seriously ill patient and an unobtainable coherent medical history. Both of these physicians attend patients at the VA Hospitals in Baltimore, MD.
They write, "Most currently available electronic medical record software is unwieldy and difficult to quickly access, and there is still no vehicle for the timely exchange of critical medical data between providers and facilities." The cardiologists note that the federal stimulus package included about $50 billion for health IT, but they argue that "it will be difficult and costly to construct new systems ensuring interoperability of all current hospital software."
This does not address the issues of outpatient clinical care, which have a far greater number of clinical encounters.
The VA system has been using VISTA as their EMR. They advocate for the adoption of the VA VISTA system as the backbone for EMR in the United States. They also suggest that any other EMRs be interoperable with the VA system. Both of these suggestions enjoy considerable merit for several reasons.
1. It is a proven stable platform
2. It has been used by many or most physicians during training.
3. It is ‘free’. This is not entirely accurate. The program itself is free of charge, but does require some expertise in tweaking it for the underlying operating system. The operating system is somewhat arcane and no longer in popular demand.
4. There is a pool of IT specialists familiar with the system that can be ‘tapped’ for implementing the system and training it’s users.
5. The suggestion that other systems be interoperable with VISTA is a good one. The standard is there….and it works! This eliminates the controversy about which standard will be adopted. There are several competing certification organizations in play at this time. This will cause delays and perhaps avoid further confusion should several different regional standards emerge.
6. VISTA is scalable.
7. The taxpayers have already invested considerable ‘billions of dollars’ in this system.
The negatives are:
1. VISTA is not well designed for independent practitioners, or small group practices.
2. It bears the perhaps unwarranted ‘stigma’ of being a government computer system, with real and/or imagined prejudices against such a system. Such as the Post Office.
3. It is an ‘older system’ designed more than 15 years ago, with multiple ‘patches’.
One of the greatest frustrations for any physician in the U.S. is the "uninsured patient". Coming face to face with one of the 'forgotten' patients can ruin an entire day of work. Knowing how to help a patient and being totally powerless to do so ranks right up there with an announced audit from the IRS and/or a letter from a plaintiff's attorney that you are about to get your a-- sued.
In fact what has evolved in most practice offices is a highly refined filtering mechanism to keep these patients away from you, the physician. This vicious and exclusionary process developed without any forethought as a means to insure the financial survival of our present health system. It flies in the face of what physicians are really all about....caring for people.
In order to see a physician you must be a 'card carrying" patient or have a wad of cash (which is rapidly evolving into a wad of plastic bits and bytes, or a wheelbarrow) At any rate the 'plastic card' now carries more power that one could have ever imagined.
At one time it did not matter, doctors and hospitals could and did give away millions of dollars of care because they were compensated fairly and sufficiently. Even if ph ysicians gave away their services (which is a small percentage of total health care costs) the patient could not access lab work, imaging services, nor have access to medications.
JOIN THE MARCH!!!
"I'm tired, mad as hell, and just not going to take it anymore," says Richard Chudacoff, MD, a gynecologist from Las Vegas. "I am going to Washington, DC. At noon, on Thursday, October 1, 2009, I will be on the Mall with a few other physicians."
How many times have YOU thought or even muttered this under your breath??
"We simply decided that we will not work that day and perhaps the day before and maybe even the day afterward," says Dr. Chudacoff. "Perhaps we will show the country that physicians are worth more than a $5 copay; that physicians are more important than a mid-level healthcare worker; and that our profession is needed, our services are required, and our practice is a calling to be respected, not a trade that is to be negotiated to the lowest bidder.
A letter posted by Dr. Chudacoff on www.obgyn.net in June has been spreading like wildfire across the Internet, finding its way to personal blogs, discussion groups, and professional forums.
On July 10, an MPC contributor and one of the supporters of the Million Med March launched a Website, www.millionmedmarch.com, to build support for the October event.
A TOWNHALL MEETING IN FREMONT CALIFORNIA WITH DEMOCRAT, PETE STARK .
Some images from the March of September 10th,2009,AND THERE WILL BE ANOTHER GATHERING ON OCTOBER 1, 2009.
Don't forget...be there on October 1, 2009
Sen. Amy Klobuchar, D-Minn., has advanced this proposal as part of her Medicare Payment Improvement Act, and it is now at the center of the Senate's discussion on how to craft health care reform.
The value index would penalize Medicare providers that spend above the national average and reward providers that spend below the national average with more funding. The idea is to raise the quality of health care and encourage efficiency, but in reality it will undercut those with the greatest health care needs, namely the poor and minorities.
By failing to consider major factors driving regional spending differences, the value index is not what proponents make it out to be. Consider this: The average monthly rent in San Mateo is $1,658 while it's $873 in Minneapolis. Salaries for medical support staff are considerably higher in California than in Midwestern states. None of that is reflected in the value index's calculation. So absent any other factors, the proposal would direct more funding to places with a lower cost of doing business, which has nothing to do with the quality or efficiency of medical treatment.
A version of the value index is part of the health care reform plan unveiled Wednesday by Sen. Max Baucus, D-Mont. (The House's health care reform bill, HR 3200, would commission a study on Medicare's spending differences and consider what to do about them at a later date.)
(these studies have been done, and are already available from previous medicare data)
A few simple solutions: Are we up to it?
From the California Health Care Foundation: Another simple solution.
Gubernatorial Candidate Campbell Offers Health Plan for California
OBAMA LIES?? or perhaps to put it more gently, HE DOESN'T KNOW WHAT HE IS TALKING ABOUT.
Recently in MedPolitics, EvanMadianosMD -discuses's the producers of health care.
The largest problem in our health cares system is....the uninsured.
Physicians when they come across uninsured patients feel great angst that they cannot order tests, or do appropriate indicated procedures for a patient. This perhaps is the greatest stress of today's medicine. This is the reason many physicians chose to work for the VA, Military System,,, or large prepaid groups such As Kaiser Permanente, the patients are pre screened already and there is no doubt for the physicians that they will be able to provide quality care.
Lumping our present health system into the supposed evils of capitalism, greed and avarice does a great disservice to all physicians and hospitals. We have been thrown into an atmosphere of rhetoric not by our actions but the misappropriation of slick phrases and comparisons to the advantages of 'socialized medicine in a 'new world order' of utopia.
Few in the arena of proponents of health care reform elaborate on the evils of that system. There is no reason our system should 'ration' health care.....physicians certainly don't do that unless they are economically coerced to do so.....at the expense of their very financial survival.
Dr EvanMadianosMD goes on further,
"In Ayn Rand's timeless novel Atlas Shrugged, the mysterious hero John Galt is a symbol of the man whose productive energy is withdrawn from the world in protest against living as the despised pawn of the state. But Ayn Rand was aware that the disappearance of the men of talent did not always happen as a deliberate act of protest; it is often just the natural outcome of any system that punishes hard work, ambition, and independent thought, discouraging and demoralizing men with those life-giving qualities. This is what some people have started referring to as "going Galt."
If we accept such a system in the medical profession, we could find ourselves paging Dr. Galt—and getting no answer. "
I wanted to thank all of you who attended the recent 'golden llama awards ceremony, attended by Representative Paul Ryan, Joe Wilson (you lie, you lie)
Vice president Joe Biden, ex VP Dick Cheney,and numerous honored guests.
I also have it from an undisclosed source who prefers to remain anonymous since (he,(she) is not authorized to make a statement) that Michelle Obama was lurking under one of the tables hoping that her husband would receive a Llama.
Mr. Obama, however was making the rounds of
CNN, MSNBC, ABC, Foxnews, NPR, CBS, CW, CNBC, SciFi, The Discovery Channel, The History Channel, and his most important appearance on "Dirty Jobs".
I should also recognize Borat and Bruno
who could not attend due to other prior commitments. Borat and Bruno have made great contributions(not) to American Healthcare (not), as well.
Health Train is honored to accept the award on behalf of Thomas the Train
and will offer free transportation to the Llamas on their way to
the awardees. (please check in 2 hours early for security screening)
It is truly an honor to receive this highly coveted award at this time in my life.
It will occupy the last remaining space on my office wall,
in lieu of any board recertification certificates.
I shall honor and treasure this award, and will submit it on my next log of CME credits....(How many CME credits do I get for it?)
From The Health Care Blog (Thank you Matt Holt)
By DANIEL PALESTRANT, MD
We are pledging our commitment to true healthcare reform focused on the real sources of spiraling, bureaucratic costs and by doing this on day one of Congress’ return, we are telling them that true healthcare reform will only succeed IF:
US physicians have a unique perspective on the systemic changes needed because we are on the forefront of care every day-in between patients, hospitals, Medicare, Medicaid, and insurance companies. Physicians more than any stakeholder group understand the need for pragmatic reform, not politically negotiated reform and we must be included for solutions to work.
With the Appeal, the SERMO community is seeking participation from every member of the US Senate to work with us to bridge a communication gap dominated by the influence of special interest groups; inviting policy makers to engage directly with us by posting questions, discussion topics and blog entries directly into the largest physicians-only online network, in an electronic online forum to discuss ideas and developments in the healthcare reform debate, in real time.
Today, in Washington, we’ll formally deliver the “US Physician’s Appeal” for lawmaker’s consideration to all 100 Senator’s offices. If you can’t be there, find us onlineat http://www.sermo.com/reform where you can sign the appeal; and then make your opinion known by getting in touch with your Senators by visiting www.senate.gov and click on “Senators”.
We have strength in numbers and if the physician voice is loud enough, it will be heard.
Dr. Daniel Palestrant is the CEO of SERMO and was recently named one of the country’s “50 Most Powerful Physicians” by Modern Physician, and Business Week has named SERMO as one of the “Top 50 Tech Startups” globally. SERMO is where over 110,000 physicians are leveraging the power of social media to drive better patient care and have their voices heard.
More by this author:
It is down to 'crunch time'. The media are calling this the biggest speech of President Obama's first year in office. The media thrives on playing off Republicans vs. Democrats, Left vs. Right.
We physicians are cynics when it comes to government and bureaucracy. We like to get down and 'dirty' and see and treat with minimal interruption, minimize record keeping, and other paperwork. Let's be real....for every patient encounter..ten minutes of recording data or notes adds up to several hours/day.
Will EMR improve efficiency? Perhaps it will if someone other than the physician enters the data. At 200 dollars/ physician hour in productivity assigning this responsibility is both foolish, and not cost effective. How many secretaries earn two hundred dollar/hour?
Physicians are a 'hard sell', by the very nature of our training, we observe, gather facts, study, analyze and render opinions, and diagnoses.
Most of us have had the privelege and ability to chose the type of organization in which we practice and see patients. Whether it is a group, large integrated healthcare organization or solo practice, we have had the ability to chose.
This weekend from September 10th through September 13th a number of physician groups will travel to Washington, D.C. to meet with their representatives. No doubt the media will be there as well.
Our angst will be shared with the unemployed, foreclosed, and uinsured, amidst a sea-change in credit markets, corporate mergers, federal bailouts of banks, financial markets, and underwriting the automobile industry, once the golden measure of American success .
Our government borrows money for many reasons...to fight wars, to fund large building projects, for operational expenses of the pentagon and many other government activities, NASA included.
Many of these activities are accomplished at the expense of healthcare. What are our priorities?
This does not seem to be a prudent time to make another revolutionary change in a segment of our economy which now represents 16% of the GDP.
Most of us patients, and providers alike see access as a problem both in terms of availablilty and affordability, as well as predatoroy insurance company practices.
We need to plug the holes in our system. There are many other health systems that do just this. Universal payor is not synonymous with socialized medicine, despite what the AMA and some physicians state.
T.R. Reid points out the strengths of the systems in France, and Switzerland, which provides guarranteed health care for all citizens.
Depending on the way of financing there are 4 healthcare models
Health Care Systems - Four Basic Models
“Semashko” model – state monopoly
“Bismark” model –social health insurance system
“Beverage” model – a combination of National Health Service and health insurance
“Kennedy” model – also a mixed system, with private structures prevailing in both healthcare and health insurance.
THE GATEKEEPER
Here it is the last of the four day weekend for me. Seems it was just Friday with three days off.
I had a chance to do much reading and study all the different propositions for health care reform.
Analysts all agree that the United States has the best quality of science, and technology available to those who can pay for it. Our system of health care payments is failing (or has failed), much like the 'bubble' in real estate, financial markets, and internet technology.
So why should we be any different?
T.R. Reid offers a dispassionate appraisal of health systems throughout the developed world. Reid is a strong proponent of unified health care delivery. He states that the best programs, such as those in Switzerland, France, Germany and Taiwan (yes Virginia, Taiwan). are actually private models, unified by universal access, universal payment standards, and governmental subsidy for those that are uninsured, or uninsurable. They are not employer based.
He espouses the opinion these systems are not 'socialized medicine systems.
His 2008 Frontline documentary, "Sick Around the World", looked at the comprehensive health care systems of five developed economies from around the world. The first two countries visited were the U.K. and Japan, where he had previously worked and also received medical care.[4] They were followed by Germany, Taiwan, and Switzerland.[5]
